Side-by-side: MVR vs CDLIS vs PSP
| Dimension | MVR (state DMV) | CDLIS (AAMVA) | PSP (FMCSA) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source | State DMV record | AAMVA federal pointer | FMCSA MCMIS via NIC Federal |
| What it shows | License status, convictions, suspensions | Every state where driver held a CDL since 1996 | Roadside inspections + reportable crashes |
| Lookback | 3 years standard, up to 7-10 years optional | Since 1996 | 5 years crashes, 3 years inspections |
| Geography | One state per pull | Nationwide pointer | Nationwide CMV inspections |
| CDL or non-CDL | Both | CDL only | Both |
| Consent | DPPA + FCRA | DPPA + FCRA | FMCSA PSP MOU + FCRA |
| Typical cost | $4-$30 per state | ~$5 per query | $10 per report |
| CFR anchor | §391.23(a) | §384.225 | §391.23(d) |
When to choose MVR alone
For non-CDL drivers with single-state license history, an MVR alone covers the §391.23(a) license-history requirement. The driver self-certifies on the §391.21 application that they have only ever been licensed in the one state, and the carrier pulls that one MVR. CDLIS is empty for a non-CDL driver (the AAMVA pointer only contains CDL events), and PSP is optional but often added as a $10 default item on the file.
For the §391.25 annual review, the MVR is the only required item. PSP is not part of the annual review (it is a §391.23 pre-employment item). CDLIS is also not part of the annual review - once a year is overkill for a pointer record that only changes when the driver applies for a new state CDL.
When to choose CDLIS
CDLIS is the discovery instrument for any CDL driver. The §391.23(a) regulation requires the carrier to obtain the violation record from every state where the driver held a license during the prior 3 years. For a CDL driver, the driver self-disclosure on the application is not enough - drivers forget, lie, or have CDL events the application form doesn’t surface. The AAMVA pointer is the authoritative answer.
CDLIS is also the §383.73 single-license enforcement mechanism. A driver may hold only one CDL across all jurisdictions; CDLIS is the database that lets a state DMV check before issuing a new CDL. For a hiring carrier, a CDLIS query that returns multiple active CDLs is a bright-line disqualifier.
When to choose PSP
PSP is the right call when the question is "what does this driver actually do on the road?" Roadside inspectors document HOS violations, equipment defects, pre-trip issues, and load-securement problems that often never escalate to a state-court conviction. None of those land on an MVR - they land on PSP. The $10 cost is small relative to the audit-defense value of having documented evidence of the §391.23(d) good-faith investigation.
PSP is also driver-centric across employers. A driver who worked for two carriers in the prior 3 years has both sets of inspection events on the same PSP report. That makes PSP a strong single source for cross-employer driving behavior - far more efficient than chasing each previous DOT-regulated employer for a §391.23(a)(2) inquiry.
Why most carriers run all three
For a CDL driver, the four-source bundle (MVR + CDLIS + PSP + Clearinghouse pre-employment query) is the operating standard. The four reports answer different §391.23 questions and the §391.51 DQ file is incomplete without the union of all four. Bundled DOT Pre-Employment ($175) packages all four because the four-report package is the operating standard for new-hire CDL screening.
For non-CDL CMV drivers, the bundle drops to MVR + PSP (no CDLIS, no Clearinghouse). PSP still applies because the FMCSA roadside-inspection program covers any CMV under §390.5, not just CDL-eligible vehicles.
Frequently asked questions
Which of the three is required by 49 CFR §391.23?
The MVR is explicitly required at §391.23(a) for every state where the driver held a license during the prior 3 years. CDLIS is required for CDL drivers at §391.23(m)(2) and is also the only practical way to satisfy the multi-state requirement - without CDLIS the carrier cannot reliably know which states to query. PSP is not strictly required but is an efficient single-report source of evidence for the §391.23(d) safety-performance investigation across all DOT-regulated employers.
Can I skip CDLIS if the driver has only ever held one state CDL?
Technically yes, but in practice carriers rarely skip CDLIS for a CDL driver. The risk of missing a prior out-of-state CDL the driver forgot to disclose is real, and a CDLIS query is inexpensive. Most carriers run CDLIS as a default item on every CDL pre-employment file.
How much does the three-report bundle cost?
For a single-state CDL driver: about $4-$30 for the MVR (state DMV fee), about $5 for CDLIS (AAMVA fee plus processing), and $10 for PSP (FMCSA fee). The DOT Pre-Employment package wraps all three plus 12 months of Clearinghouse query management (including the §382.701(a) query) for $175, with bundled DPPA + FCRA + Clearinghouse consent on a single intake.
Related comparisons
Run MVR + CDLIS + PSP in one order
The DOT Pre-Employment package bundles MVR + CDLIS + PSP + 12 months of Clearinghouse query management (including the §382.701(a) pre-employment query) for $175, with one consent form covering all four sources. We order the driver records you choose from the issuing state, AAMVA and FMCSA, with the driver consents collected at checkout, and email you the reports as PDFs. From $50 (MVR Basic) to $175 (DOT Pre-Employment).
Independent screening service operated by Fast Filing Group LLC. Not affiliated with FMCSA, USDOT, AAMVA, any state DMV or any government agency.
Timing depends on the issuing state, AAMVA and FMCSA; reports are emailed as PDFs as each source returns them. The reports are records, not a hiring recommendation: the motor carrier reviews them and makes the qualification decision under 49 CFR Part 391.
This page is informational and is not legal advice. Verify regulatory requirements against the current text of 49 CFR Part 391 before relying on this comparison.
Authoritative citations
Related guides
PSP vs MVR vs CDLIS
The Pre-Employment Screening Program, the Motor Vehicle Record, and the Commercial Driver License Information System all sound similar. Here is what they actually show.
Read the PSP vs MVR vs CDLIS guideCDLIS vs MVR
A Motor Vehicle Record only shows what one state knows. CDLIS is the federal database of every CDL ever issued. Here is what each report catches.
Read the CDLIS vs MVR guideDOT Pre-Employment Checklist
Every check FMCSA requires before a new CDL driver's first dispatch - MVR, Clearinghouse query, drug test, safety performance history - with deadlines and citations.
Read the DOT Pre-Employment Checklist guide